Advertisement 87
Advertisement 347
Petitioners’ counsel Al Elliott, Foreign Affairs Minister Dwight FitzGerald Bramble, and petitioners’ attorney Carlos James leaving the High Court in Kingstown on Thursday, Nov. 12, 2026.
Petitioners’ counsel Al Elliott, Foreign Affairs Minister Dwight FitzGerald Bramble, and petitioners’ attorney Carlos James leaving the High Court in Kingstown on Thursday, Nov. 12, 2026.
Advertisement 219

Foreign Affairs Minister Dwight Fitzgerald Bramble says the election petition battle has left him “more fortified” to serve Vincentians, while the counsel for the petitioners rejects claims that the challenge stems from losing at the polls.

Petitioners’ counsel Al Elliott addressed the media last Thursday following the conclusion of closing arguments in the High Court election petitions challenging the parliamentary eligibility of Prime Minister Godwin Friday and Bramble.

The petitions, filed by unsuccessful Unity Labour Party (ULP) candidates Augustus Carlos Williams and Luke Browne following the November 2025 general election, seek to invalidate the elections of Friday and Bramble. 

Both Friday and Bramble, members of the governing New Democratic Party (NDP), hold Canadian citizenship.

Under Section 26(1)(a) of the Constitution of St. Vincent and the Grenadines, individuals who voluntarily acknowledge allegiance, obedience, or adherence to a foreign power or state are disqualified from sitting in Parliament—a provision the petitioners argue invalidates the two MPs’ elections.

Advertisement 271

The respondents counter that their status as Commonwealth citizens protects their eligibility to sit in Parliament under Section 25 of the Constitution.

Outside the courthouse, Elliott rejected the narrative that the petitioners were pursuing the matter because of the election results—a characterisation Friday echoed in October when he described the challenges to reporters as “sour grapes and sore losers.” 

Elliott said that characterisation is unfair to Williams and Browne. 

“Suffice it to say that these petitioners would have filed an objection prior to the election, prior to nominations, objecting to the nominations of Dr. Friday and Mr. Bramble. So they would’ve started their action before they would have known the outcome of the elections,” Elliott said.

He maintained that, “win, lose or draw,” the constitutional issue required judicial determination—which, he said, is why they proceeded after the election.

Bramble, who also spoke with reporters last Thursday, described himself as a “social scientist” and called the court case a “political sociological” strategy by the opposition to “suppress” the will of the people.

“Plain and simple, that is my interpretation, and the fact that I have had to endure this debilitating exercise, for me, reinforces my commitment to serve my people,” Bramble said.

He continued his point, saying that regardless of how the judgment turns out, he is “more fortified” to serve the people of East Kingstown and SVG.

Another attorney for the petitioners, Carlos James, told reporters that he is satisfied his team has concluded its submissions before the court. 

James said the case boils down to a narrow interpretation of the law regarding who is qualified and disqualified from contesting a general election—specifically what constitutes a foreign power or state.

“And it is now for Her Ladyship to go and make that determination based on what submissions we have put forward, both from the petitioners and also from the respondents in this matter, and to deliberate and to return with her judgment,” James added.

James said the petitioners hope the ruling brings clarity to the constitutional provisions governing candidate eligibility so the country can move forward.

“But this is far beyond Dr. Friday, Mr. Bramble, Carlos Williams, and Luke Browne. It is really settling with great clarity the legal prescription that is required…” James continued.

He said that in 10 to 25 years, dual citizens or individuals who have sworn allegiance to a foreign power may seek to contest elections. 

“It is far beyond the political climate. It is really that constitutional interpretation, not just for St. Vincent and the Grenadines, but other Commonwealth member states and other countries within the Eastern Caribbean that are part of the Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court — in terms of the Caribbean states who can now follow the pattern of development that has taken place with election petition hearings and the laws that are associated within this jurisprudence,” James said.

High Court Judge Justice Gertel Thom indicated she will deliver her judgment in the new law term.

Start the Discussion

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.