The main opposition New Democratic Party (NDP), on Wednesday, circulated to the media a leaked copy of the 2018 poverty assessment, which shows that between 2008 and 2018, poverty in St. Vincent and the Grenadines had moved from 30.2% to 36.1% of the population.

What’s more, the indigence level had moved from 2.9% to 11.3% in the country of 110,000 people.

Further, 45.4% of the population were at risk of sliding into poverty, down from 48.2% a decade earlier, the only category in which there was favourable movement.

The report shows that the nation’s rich are getting richer even as the poor decline into further poverty and that the wages that the government pays to some categories of workers, including Youth Empowerment Services (YES) staff, were below the poverty line.

The Poverty Assessment Report is produced every 10 years and the opposition had made several attempts in Parliament, before its Oct. 9 dissolution, to get Minister of Finance Camillo Gonsalves, to release the data.

“It’s a troubling report,” Opposition Leader Godwin Friday told an NDP press conference on Wednesday, where the figures were released.

Friday, who is making his first attempt to become prime minister, called on the Ralph Gonsalves Unity Labour Party (ULP) government to “do their obligation to the people, to, basically, level with them and tell them what the conditions are, and explain why we are at the point where we are now”.

At the same press conference, NDP chairman and incumbent MP for West Kingstown said that the government had ordered the staff preparing the report to halt work on it in early 2019.

And Friday said that the government must tell the people why the report was not completed and published — as had been the case previously  — “so that we can know where we are, so that there’s validation amongst the people as to what their condition is”.

The opposition leader said that the report shows that people are not simply complaining in the absence of hardships, as a ULP supporter had told him while he was campaigning in Clare Valley recently.

“…their (the government’s) own assessment proves that the pain that people are feeling, the expressions of hardship that we see around the country are real,” Friday said.

He continued:

“And it is urgent because if you can imagine now that with COVID-19, that the situation has deteriorated dramatically. And when I called on the Parliament to put the money where the pain is, that is no idle request. The pain is real. And it is growing according to the government’s statistics.”

Friday was responding to his criticism of how the government had allocated funds in a supplementary budget, passed with opposition support, in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.

The report defines the Poverty Line as the minimum expenditure required by an individual/household to meet their basic food and non-food needs.

And, in 2018, the annual poverty line had increased by EC$1,024 over the previous decade, reaching to EC$6,547.

The report further states that the Indigent/food line is based on the minimum amount of money needed to purchase some basic food bundle.

Households or persons unable to meet the cost of obtaining these basic food items are categorised as critically poor, indigent or food poor.

And, to stay above the poverty line, a household had to generate EC$6,547 annually, EC$1,024 more than it did in 2008, to stay above the poverty line.

And in 2018, a household needed to generate EC$696 more annually than it did in 2008, for a total of EC$3,142, to avoid falling into indigence.

The annual non-food line had increased by EC$328 to EC$3,405, the report said.

The data show that in 2008, a household had to generate income of at least EC$204 per adult per month to live above the indigence line, while the figure had risen by EC$58 per month in 2018, reaching EC$262.

And, in order to avoid falling below the poverty vulnerability line, EC$107 more was needed monthly in 2018, for a total of EC$682, compared to EC$575 in 2008, the vulnerability line being 1.25 times the poverty line.

The report says that the 2017 labour force shows that 11.8% of the population was living in households reporting having fewer meals as a result of lack of money or resources.

This figure mirrors that of the 2018 indigent population.

And, when 30 days was used as the reference point, the 2017 labour force shows that 24.2% of the population was living in households which reported having fewer meals as a result of lack of money or resources.

This figure is close to that of 2018, with the reference being 12 months.

Cummings said:

“This information was made available to the government of this country for a long time and their response was to make sure the population never sees it.

“We thank God that there are responsible persons in this country who understand the importance of the public being aware of this information and have made it possible, by an angelic intervention, for us to be able to bring it to you today,” Cummings said.

Cummings reiterated that the data point to the situation before the COVID-19 pandemic.

“And this is as at 2018. I keep making the point,” he said, noting that the report had put the vulnerability index near 50%.

“I just want to reiterate, this report, this study, was done well in advance of COVID. And everybody knows St. Vincent’s economy has nosedived since COVID so you can imagine what the figures would be if this study were done today. It is frightening,” Cummings said.

The opposition held the press conference weeks after Cummings threatened to release the information if the government did not, and after he began citing section of the report during the campaign for the Nov. 5 general elections.

Prime Minister Ralph Gonsalves, speaking at a campaign event after Cummings first gave specific figures, said that poverty had fallen under his administration but gave no particular numbers to support this, as he had done after the 2008 poverty assessment.

6 replies on “Leaked report paints grim picture of poverty in SVG”

  1. Is anyone in SVG surprised by these dreadful figures? Poverty and Unemployment are surely directly related, therefore, what a tragedy it is for the people of St Vincent and the Grenadines, to have a selfish deluded tyrant and his family in charge of SVG Limited.

    This self-styled “papa” we know, mirrors the behaviours of the Communist Kim’s in North Korea, former Mao of China, the Castro’s of Cuba and the unworkable communist policies of his friends in Venezuela. And surely we see what unemployment and poverty such policies had caused to those countries people too.

    Can we not learn from their tragic history? Must Vincentians remain dunce to the tragedy of national unemployment and gross poverty and who is causing such?

  2. None of this is a surprise to me. Many of us have been seeing this coming for over 10 years, some from even before that. There is so much VERY WRONG with our economics in SVG and any warnings to make necessary changes have been ignored.
    Some people on this site have said that many of us never bring up solutions: UNTRUE!
    The very WORST THING one can do is constantly raise taxes. Remember at the 2008 global economic crisis our government cut concessions: BAD MOVE! All the entities building hotels in the country stopped and left taking the jobs and future prospects with them, to INTELLIGENT COUNTRIES LIKE SINGAPORE that instead LOWERED TAXES!
    Our Corporate Income tax should be no higher than 21% (I would have it at 15%). The “public sector” ( I call it the government sector because it has little to do with the “public”) Is far too large. Why do we need 5 Vincentians to do the job and accomplish the amount of work that One person does in most efficient countries? The problem is that releasing all these people creates more unemployment so it is necessary to have a place for them to go in the private sector. In order for the private sector to create jobs the government sector has to provide an environment for the private sector to prosper. This is not done by raising taxes and taking the lion’s share of all the profits! Government has to (AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE):
    CREATE AN ENVIRONMENT WHERE PROSPERITY IS INEVITABLE AND POVERTY IS IMPOSSIBLE!
    Instead they have been doing the opposite.
    I could go on and on about implementing what I see as needed changes but the reader should already be getting the point. Government may want to try to see how they can get prosperity to the people instead of trying to get prosperity for the government because, as we see…We eventually get neither!

    In real society (as opposed to socialist fantasy) prosperity is determined by the size and wealth of the middle-class not by the wealth of the government or the amount of people on poor relief. Here government seems to want a larger lower-class. Just see the manifesto of the ULP. Where does one think all the money comes from to do all these things they WANT to do but are rarely able?….The money comes from more and more taxes, primarily from the middle-class, destroying the ability of businesses and causing a bigger and bigger lower-class. So much in SVG is done the wrong way. Even Pryme Grants does not create opportunity for all. It unfairly gives free money to the “chosen”. Better to drastically lower taxes than try to create favoritism in an environment that cannot sustain most new businesses. Most of these businesses will not even be able to export because the world does not want to pay for the higher cost it takes to produce anything in SVG; driven-up by high taxes because overseas markets would rather buy elsewhere.

    Some high people in government could benefit from a class in Classical Economics 101 instead of Socialism fantasies 499.

    I thank Kenton for this site where we can all educate eachother through comments, and possibly those in government as well, that seem to have gotten an INDOCTRINATION instead of an education. If they care about this country they should realize what they have been doing is not working. If they have not realized that by now…

  3. Here we go again .what next people what next you need to hear and know to ,try something different times up people we give them ULP all the time they need to do right by we the people but they ulp make things worst and worst , TIME FOR A CHANGE PEOPLE WAKE UP LISTEN AND THINK FOR YOUR SELF

  4. Stalin called together his closest comrades-in-arms. “I understand you’re wondering how I govern the people so that every last one of them … thinks of me as a living god. Now I’ll teach you the right attitude toward the people.” And he ordered a chicken brought in. He plucked it live, in front of them all, down to the last feather, down to the red flesh, until only the comb was left on its head. “And now watch,” he said, and let the chicken go. It could have gone off where it wished, but it went nowhere. It was too hot in the sun and too cold in the shade. The poor bird could only press itself against Stalin’s boots. And then he tossed it a crumb of grain, and the bird followed him wherever he went. Otherwise, it would have fallen over from hunger. “That,” he told his pupils, “is how you govern our people.”

  5. Quo vadis, I believe every word, in your comment, I think something is truly wrong with some of us black poor people, something is seriously wrong.

Comments are closed.