Historian and retired head of the University of the West Indies Open Campus, Dr. Adrian Fraser, says the region must pursue reparations from Europe but he does not think much will come of the effort.
“I think it is something which we really should do; it is something that we are, more or less, forced to do,” he told I-Witness News on the sidelines of the National Garifuna Conference on Saturday.
“I am not sure that there is going to be any success down the road, because it is a question of power. We don’t have the power, and they (Europe) will simply neglect us and they probably feel that once they do that (pay reparations), it is going to open a can of worms,” said Fraser, who delivered the feature address during the opening ceremony of the conference.
(Read Dr. Fraser’s address “Back to our Roots — Strategies for Survival and Sustainability of Indigenous Peoples in SVG”)
Caribbean Community (CARICOM) heads of government have reported “good progress” on reparations after their meeting here last week and have set up a commission that will report back to them during their summit in July.
But Fraser said he does not expect, “at least in the short run”, that the region will get “much” from its efforts to get Europe to pay compensation for African slavery and native genocide.
“… but I feel it is something which we need to do, because of the way our history is bastardised and the way our people suffered over that period of time,” Fraser told I-Witness News.
“So, we are compelled to do it. As part of trying to reclaim our history and recognising what has happened in the past and also bringing before the international public the fact that Britain, and the Europeans generally, benefitted tremendously from us.
“We provided the springboard for their entry into industrialisation. That was not the only thing, but we played a very important role in it. So, we need to make that statement and we need to let the world understand what happened with us,” Fraser told I-Witness News.
During his lecture, Fraser said there must be a consensus on what the region needs from the reparations.
“Not to do this is to admit that we are not serious,” he said.
He said that a large part of the reparations effort should focus on the indigenous people.
“We should have some understanding, particularly where indigenous people are concerned, what we want out of reparation, what we would do with whatever is offered us through reparation. …Unless we do that, it will show that we are not serious about it,” he told I-Witness News.
Dr. Fraser is smart enough to know that the Reparations issue is a cynical politcial gimmick mean to win votes for Caricom leaders in future elections.
If the logic of Dr. Frazer is to be followed, until the Kenyans settle their internal problems then the Mau Mau should not have pursued reparations from Britain. I am glad they did not follow Dr. Frazer’s logic.
Vincentians should be sorely disappointed with Dr. Fraziers negative remarks about the call for reparation. One would imagine that Dr Frazier as a black man, a noted Vincentian historian, would be one of the first to support the cause, to champion the call for reparations and not one to trivialize it in such a shameful, spineless manner.
On the one hand he thinks … it is something which we really should do but on the other hand, hes …not sure that there is going to be any success down the road. What? Well, thats the doctors opinion. I suppose he is entitled to his opinion. Nevertheless, Dr Fraziers remarks should be placed on the rubbish heap.
When one is not supportive of our demands for restitution, they should get out of the way, and keep their negative responses to themselves, as I hope Dr Frazier would, and not let the word get out that we have weak-hearts amongst us. Forward ever backward never!